Is the Apple iPhone really innovative or revolutionary, or simply the next in an evolution of converging electronics?
I am a complete Mac-head with cash to spend but I am really, really struggling with the parting of $600 for a poor man’s computer on a network that actually does suck (compared with, say, a $600 table set that could ruin your entire patio). It really would be like buying a Ferrari with an 80mph speed limiter. Why would anyone do that? There’s no sense in that.
I am on AT&T today with a shiny BlackBerry Pearl (standard work issue) and EDGE is not fast on the BlackBerry’s awful yet minimal browser. It’s not even average. It’s downright slow.
So take that slowness on a lesser capable device, my expectation therefore is exceptionally low for downloading full pages to the iPhone. And what about all those other gorgeous features?
YouTube - maybe I’m one of the few human beings who visited that site once for an hour or two, then got bored and moved on with my life. YouTube on a phone? No thanks. It’s the same as watching America’s Funniest Videos. If there’s nothing else to watch on TV, put that on in the background while I do something useful. Not in my top 15 things I’d have on a portable Mac.
Google Maps - now this would have been cool if there was a built-in GPS device in the phone. No GPS… what use is Google Maps in a portable device other than a glorified phone directory?
Here’s a killer app - I can zoom into photos with my fingers. Yay. I zoom into photos in Adobe Photoshop to correct images. Why the hell would I want to zoom on an iPhone? And in glorious, color accurate, massive resolution. Um, no.
Then there’s the downsides too… can’t replace the battery yourself (read: $100). No slot for extra memory (read: 8Gb will do you for, um, three weeks? And how much space does your iPod have today?). Did I mention *yawn* EDGE? North America has always been notoriously slow for adoption of new electronic technologies… however 3G networks have existed for at least a year in this country. Why use 2.1G?
As much an Apple junkie as I am; in my view it is not worth $600 plus a minimum of $60 a month into a typically screw-over cellphone provider two year $170+ to leave, sign your life away contract. Do you know what phone you’ll want in two years time? What will Apple have released by then that you’ll drool over but can’t’ do anything about?
Oh, and you need a contract to use the iPod features… bend over and take one from AT&T early adopters of the world!
I’m waiting for the next generation of iPhone. Maybe the one after that.
UPDATE: Eating my words… I bought one on launch day. It’s actually much better than I thought it would be. Still not happy about the AT&T contract though. Two years sucks.